"or if this is just the writers interpretation'

Could be.....however, if he's reading the transcripts....they can be very telling.

"if true, hoe highly does this speak about Apples legal team, if the judge has to tell their team how to do their job? "

"At first sight, this is a major disappointment for Apple, which had already amended its complaint (which it originally brought in February 2012) once in order to address flaws raised by an earlier Motorola motion. "

They got it wrong twice before being shut down....

doni