DABOSS:...It is called DEDUCTIVE REASONING, and your following paragraph is a good example of it...

See you next week; as KIRK says, the PLANETS ARE ALIGHNED...Lol...Lol...

Gil...

The accused products range from digital cameras and camcorders to voice recorders and mobile phones.

The EDIG-portalplayer relationship is well established and portalplayer was an intergral part in the makeup for the ipod. What technology they may have encroached on remains to be seen but chances are Apple is right in the middle of this. Of course, this is just my opinion, but if NOKIA is an infringer as a cell phone maker with a digital camera inside then I don't see why Apple would be any different. Then there is the line of other flash products Apple has dominated the market with for the past 8 years or so.