I believe the civil minutes from the hearing would state who was present.

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA SAN JOSE DIVISION Magistrate Judge Paul S. Grewal Courtroom 5 - 4th Floor

Civil Minute Order

Date: November 30, 2012 Time in Court: 4 hours

Courtroom Deputy Clerk: Oscar Rivera Court Reporter: Gina Galvan Colin TITLE: Acer, Inc., et al. v. Technology Properties Limited, et al. CASE NUMBER: CV08-00877 PSG (Related Case: CV08-00882 PSG) Plaintiff Attorney(s) present: Heidi Keefe, Mark Weinstein, Kyle Chen, Brandon Baum, Timothy Walker and Harold Davis Defendant Attorney(s) present: James Otteson, Charles Hoge and Michelle Breit Also present: Special Master, Thomas Denver PROCEEDINGS: CV08-00877 PSG (Acer, Inc., et al. v. Technology Properties Limited, et al.) CV08-00882 PSG (HTC Corporation, et al. v. Technologies Properties Limited, et al.) 1.) Tutorial 2.) Claims Construction 3.) Plaintiffs’ Motion for Reconsideration of Certain Aspects of First Claim Construction