Simple and I'm not arguing but if there is a genuine shortage of industrial silver it will show up in Price be it in the Comex or in London. If it is just a retail shortage of coins and small bars it may take time for the manufactures to ramp up but may not affect industrial supplies.

So I'll put the question out there, give me a timeframe for when the gold silver ration should drop below 45 which was resistance this year? and if it doesnt happen can we say here was never a real shortage