The rules of the board are set by Agoracom and it is up to members to police the board. There is absolutly nothing wrong with negative criticism as long as it falls under the six rules. There are other ways of criticising the CEO for missed forward looking statements and targets other than calling him a liar. I think that is the point Lunch was making. If this board was all about pumping only, why was First Class banned from the discussion. If anybody wants to bring up anything that they perceive to be a drag on SP, they should do so. Simply state facts as facts, and if it is an opinion state it as an opinion. The last thing I want this board to do is degenerate into a pissing contest. I have read through a ton of information on this board and I am the one that decides how to use that information.