You are correct to wonder why two new posters would say what they have....... I put it down to their "lack of good experiences" ..
Why anyone would automatically think, that he or she, should be so critical in his first posts on Agoracom.. is totally beyond me.
Had he or she been a member with more experience , I believe they could or would realize their negative comments do very little... but annoy a true investor with a little patience.
...I now wish them both... all the luck in the world