As a followup, the doc no that contains the ruling is 644. The text is below and the part relating to the ruling is, I believe, at 1235PM. <<<<<<>>>>>> Courtroom Deputy Clerk: Oscar Rivera Court Reporter: Lee-Anne Shortridge TITLE: HTC Corporation, et al. v. Technology Properties Limited, et al. CASE NUMBER: CV08-00882 PSG Plaintiff Attorney(s) present: Heidi Keefe, Stephen Smith, Ron Lemieux and Matthew Leary. Also present: Vincent Lam. Defendant Attorney(s) present: James Otteson, David Lansky, Charles Hoge, Philip Marsh, Thomas Carmack and Michelle Breit. PROCEEDINGS: Jury Trial (Day 5) 9:07 AM: Hearing is held outside the presence of the jury. 9:20 AM: Jury is summoned. All 9 jurors are present. The court gives curative instruction to the jury. 9:21 AM: Continue direct examination of Stephen Prowse by D. Lansky. Mr. Prowse previously sworn. 9:38 AM: Begin cross examination by H. Keefe. 10:40 AM: Redirect by D. Lansky. 10:46 AM: Sidebar held to discuss juror questions for Mr. Prowse. 10:47 AM: End sidebar. Mr. Prowse addresses juror questions. 10:54 AM: Mr. Prowse is excused. Jury is excused for mid-morning recess. Hearing is held outside the presence of the jury. 10:56 AM: Court takes mid-morning recess. 11:17 AM: Hearing is held outside the presence of the jury. 11:19 AM: Jury is summoned. Gloria Felcyn is sworn for testimony. 11:20 AM: Begin direct examination by C. Hogue. 12:35 PM: Hearing is held outside the presence of the jury. Plaintiffs present their Rule 50(a) motions. The court grants Rule 50(a) motion as to any contributory infringement claim. The court grants Rule 50(a) motion on D.O.E. claim. The court denies Rule 50(a) motion as to literal infringement, wilfulness, inducement and damages. 12:47 PM: Jury is summoned. Martin Fichter is sworn for testimony. Begin direct examination by H. Keefe. 1:13 PM: Begin cross examination by T. Carmack. 1:20 PM: Redirect examination by H. Keefe. No questions from the jury proposed to Mr. Fichter. Mr. Fichter is excused. Sina Dena is sworn for testimony. Begin direct examination by S. Smith. 1:47 PM: 1:58 PM: 1:59 PM: 2:06 PM: 2:07 PM: 2:10 PM: 2:31 PM: 2:32 PM: afternoon 2:33 PM: 2:50 PM: 2:52 PM: Cheung sworn. 2:54 PM: Begin direct examination by H. Keefe. 2:56 PM: The court instructs the jury to rely on Mr. Liang’s english translation. Continue direct examination by H. Keefe. Begin cross examination by P. Marsh. Sidebar held. End sidebar. Continue cross examination by P. Marsh. Redirect examination by S. Smith. Sidebar held to discuss juror questions for Mr. Dena. End sidebar. Mr. Dena addresses juror questions. Further examination by P. Marsh. Further examination by S. Smith. Mr. Dena is excused. The jury is excused for mid- recess. Hearing is held outside the presence of the jury. The court takes mid-afternoon recess. Hearing is held outside the presence of the jury. Jury is summoned. Yu Hsin Liang is sworn for testimony. Mandarin interpreter Kasie 3:19 PM: Begin cross examination by T. Carmack. 3:39 PM: Redirect examination by H. Keefe. 3:40 PM: No questions from the jury proposed to Mr. Liang. Mr. Liang is excused. 3:41 PM: Christopher Bokhart is sworn for testimony. Begin direct examination by H. Keefe. 4:29 PM: Jury is excused for the weekend and instructed not to discuss case. To return 9/30/13 at 9:00 AM. Hearing is held outside the presence of the jury. 4:35 PM: Attorneys to return 9/30/13 at 9:00 AM. 11:33 AM: Begin cross examination by R. Lemieux. 11:36 AM: Sidebar held. 11:38 AM: End sidebar. Continue cross examination by R. Lemieux. 11:40 AM: Redirect by C. Hogue. No questions from the jury proposed to Ms. Felcyn. Ms. Felcyn is excused. Jury is excused for lunch. Hearing is held outside the presence of the jury. 11:41 AM: The court takes lunch break.