Paul,
I agree with you that we are not in a position to judge. However, Gildea is in a position to judge and he already said that Garmin's argument about the Domestic Industry was not to be denied. Regardless of what PTSC invested and/or TPL invested prior to the 2009 re-exam, the Judge ruled that Garmin's argument about what was invested since 2009 can't be ignored, it just needs to be proven wrong. Having a Domestic Industry is a requirement of the ITC.
That is all I will say on this subject (until further information becomes available). Like you, I wish nothing but success for Otteson, PTSC and all of us who have been holding for such a very long time.
Laurie