The examiner simply did not understand the Patent and the German Examiner and the dozens if not hundreds of Patent attorneys and engineers that have scrutinized it, do understand it.

Logic says the Patent will be sustained in a short time, however, it's good to know they have finally gotten around to it. Strict time deadlines are in place now and jonahlomu's posted argument is irrefutable in my opinion.

I majored in logic and have passed the Florida bar and although that's not much, I believe that jonahlomu's argument would convince any intelligent person.

Is there an English translation of the correct German Patent examiners final findings? If already posted I apologize I haven't seen it.

Thanks, Jim