apatentlawyer posted: "It sounds like this maxim may apply to both parties. When the Court says that it does not like your argument, something better is required than simply repeating your argument or saying that you have nothing to add. The Court read the papers; if he is not persuaded by you yet, punting surely won't get you any closer."

So apatentlawyer are you saying that Roger Cook punted and that's not usually a good move?

DW