Gartman rationale for Watershed gold call this week
posted on
Jul 03, 2013 05:45PM
Golden Minerals is a junior silver producer with a strong growth profile, listed on both the NYSE Amex and TSX.
FYI for anyone interested:
COMMENTS ON THE
CAPITAL MARKETS
TODAY WE TAKE A STAND AND WE
TURN BULLISH OF GOLD: Our long
standing readers known that we use the term
WATERSHED with a great deal of reluctance. It is our
term for a great shift in sentiment on our part, and great
shifts in sentiment by definition should happen only very,
very rarely. In our case, we believe that to be true and
our history has shown that when we’ve turned we’ve
turned properly. History has also shown what we’ve not
shown the courage of our own conviction long enough to
profit as handsomely as we should have, although our
readers have many times shown greater ability to take
these shifts in sentiment in hand, have refused to be
tossed about by day-to-day gyrations, and have reaped
enormous profits as we got tossed about by modestly
changing economic winds..
We are this morning denoting a WATERSHED shift in
sentiment away from a bearish stance on gold to a bullish
one instead, for we although we’ve been bullish of gold in
Yen terms over the course of the past year or so (and
that has actually served us reasonably well given the long
term trend of gold in terms of the Japanese Yen, but
clearly not because gold has risen but because the Yen
has weakened… and we are likely to see a good deal
more of the latter and perhaps now a bit of the former
too) we have erred in the past many months toward
things bearish of gold. We’ve raised the ire and the anger
of the Gold Bugs in the process, but we are joining their
case once again as the level of antipathy toward gold has
reached what seems to us to be almost unprecedented
levels. The level of bearishness toward gold has become
so egregious that on Friday having chosen to cover a
recent trade wherein we were long of stocks and crude
oil, and short of gold and having made the comment on
television early Friday morning that we were shifting our
position with gold down $10/ounce mid-morning we heard
one or two commentators refer to our decision to cover
as ill-advised and plainly wrong. We heard nothing but
gold bearish commentary in the various media; we
listened to nothing other than projections of lower… and
materially lower… prices that were to be on the horizon.
The airwaves were majestically bearish; we are turning
bullish as a result.
We are going to make this a double shift in sentiment
here also… a leap of faith perhaps of dangerous
proportions… in that we are going to be bullish of gold in
terms of shares, not of bullion. For the past several years
we have relentlessly said, missing not an opportunity
here or in presentations, speeches and television
appearances to make the case that it was preposterous,
silly and just-plain-wrong to be bullish of gold shares
when, if one wanted to effect a bullish outlook on gold,
one could best do so via the futures (especially with
interest rates at record lows, making the contango that
one would have to pay to own deferred futures historically
low… even perhaps negligibly so). We vilified any
investment in gold mining shares (save for purchases of
the largest miners and funds, including, but not limited to
Barrick, Goldcorp, Newmont, ASA Ltd. and a very few
other large companies, eschewing anything that might be
even mildly speculative in nature) and made mention only
marginally of the gold ETF, GLD. Henceforth we are
going to focus our attention upon the above mentioned
mining companies (although to continue to be “friends”
with the SEC, we shall only very rarely mention their
names again for we are precluded from commenting
upon individual equities and shall refrain from doing so as
much as is reasonably and wisely possible) and upon
GDX, the Market Vectors gold miners ETF. GDX is
comprised primarily of Goldcorp (13.3% of the fund);
Barrick (10.7%); Newmont (9.9%); Randgold (4.8%);
Yamana Gold (4.8%); Silver Wheaton (4.8%); and
Agnico-Eagle (4.6). These seven miners are 53% of the
funds portfolio, with the remaining 47% comprised of
smaller and very probably more leveraged miners.
GDX has massively under-performed gold in the past
nearly two years, and is now back to the same price that
existed when spot gold was trading nearer to $1000/oz.,
or if one wants to look at it another way, GDX has fallen
nearly 62% in price from its high in the autumn of ’11
while spot gold has fallen “only” 27%. The process of
mining companies taking write-downs on their ill-times
expansions in the course of the past several years has
begun, with Newcrest Mining in Australia beginning the
process last week when it wrote down a stunning $5.5
billion (A$6.0 billion). More shall follow for if we’ve
learned anything in the business of gold mining it is that
the miners are the most lemming-like of companies,
waiting for a leader to make a move but then following in
like-fashion hard upon. Now that Newcrest has lost its
write-down virginity, others shall follow swiftly behind…
rest very assured of that. As these write-downs happen,
look for something amazing to take place: the share
prices of the companies in question will hold steady
rather than faltering, and in the days, weeks and months
ahead, there shall come a time when a gold miner will
announce a material write-down and their shares will
open materially higher! Such is the nature of the
investment beast.
Finally, we have been bullish of gold in Yen terms and we
are not changing our view even slightly. Indeed, we are
more bullish now of gold/Yen than we were previously, so
when we buy gold, almost certainly we shall do so in Yen
terms, for the Bank of Japan has been, is and shall in the
next several years be far more accommodative than shall
the Fed be. Erring in favour owning gold in Yen terms has
served us far better than being long of gold in US dollar
terms, and in the months ahead owning gold shares in
Yen terms shall do the same. We’ll be buying GDX and
we’ll be selling Yen against it in equal dollar sums most of
the time, and we expect to be served well in both
instances. ‘nuff said; ‘tis time to get to work.