I agree that in Adam Smith's perfect world that might have been the case.

In this world where the Pentagon hires thousands of bloggers to post false information, where the regulators of our markets will not enforce the few laws we have, where congress refuses to regulate derivatives , where algorithm programs meet upticks in stock prices with sell orders, where the media will not report the truth, where the financial channels always say gold and silver are bubbles, where concentrated long positions are illegal and concentrated short positions are backed by the government...

Well no....you are completely wrong and a bit naive.