I was in my chat last night experimenting the same thing with another member.  I would see his go up by a few points but he wouldn't.  I would play with the stars and see it go up or down on my end but he didn't at his.  I even went in and out of the post to see if it had to do a "save" of his stars.  Nope.  But I just gave you 6 more points by doing a 5 star on you.  I see 8838 as your total at the moment.  But get this...I click 1 star and you are 8412...2 stars, you are 8518, 3 stars 8628, 4 stars still 8628...and NOW your 5 stars is only worth 8735.  I dunno.  Agora Guys, can we have a 101 on star awarding?  Makes not much sense to me.

{