Patrick Xavier Willard,

You said: "What value would they use 1.80 would interest me. But .50 would not be worth the trouble. Those 2 examples or not the same as this paper deal. Are there any examples of paper deals and dissenting?"

Please understand that in dissent remedy, the court is trying to value you as a standalone company... as such, the judge would give a lot more weight to other metrics such as NAV or DCF than how much paper you were offered. I have not found other more similar cases. However it's the line of reasoning used by the court that is more important.