Everyone is trying to make it out like this has already been discussed and settled. A lot of things have been discussed at length, but I don't think this has. So here is a fresh topic, uncluttered with other views or assumptions.

A simple question:

Why should we invest more money in Carmax now?

I think it very relevant right now, it has been a recent topic of discussion and I haven't seen any explaination as to why this would be a good idea. Lets not bundle this question into anything else.

Can it stand on its own? Lets discuss it specifically. Maybe my perception can be changed? Its not fight club, we can talk about it...