Your very correct when you speak of social responsibility, however, part of social responsibility is for governments to create the enviroment for their citizens to be prosperous. When governments fail to do so it is not up to industry to fix the problem. If they do..... it only incourages policies that are even more harmfull.

please see the article below which clearly points out why companies like Xtrata need to make choices as they've done. The operative word here is "stable"........Chasing business away and then buying it back only to chase it away again does not instill confidence.

by the Fraser Institute

Mining industry executives rate Quebec as the world's most attractive jurisdiction for mineral exploration and development for the third straight year, according to the annual survey of mining companies 2009/2010, released today by the Fraser Institute.

"Mining executives say Quebec remains an international standout for investment because its stable government policies offer them the certainty that reduces risk for long-term projects," said Fred McMahon, co-ordinator of the survey and the institute's vice-president of international policy research.

But while mining executives put Quebec at the head of the class in Canada, they have a much less optimistic view of Ontario and British Columbia, citing multiple layers of regulation, little co-ordination between various government agencies and uncertainty around aboriginal land claims.

Both Ontario and British Columbia, two provinces with a lengthy history of mining, fell significantly in this year's survey. Ontario is ranked 22nd overall, down from its 10th place finish last year, while British Columbia is even further back at 38th, dropping 14 places from the 24th spot in 2009.

"Ontario's recent throne speech indicated Dalton McGuinty's government is open to the idea of increased mining in Northern Ontario, but based on responses from the mining industry in this survey, the government has substantial work to do at fixing policies that the industry perceives as discouraging mining," Mr. McMahon said.

kind regards......Carry